The Best Bully Sticks of 2025

Brutus & Barnaby’s bully sticks are a great choice for dog owners looking for a fully digestible, natural chew. These bully sticks are made from grass-fed, free-range beef, ensuring they are safe and healthy for your pet. As a result, these sticks not only promote dental health but also provide a satisfying chewing experience that can keep your dog occupied for extended periods.

While some customers have noted inconsistency in the size and thickness of the sticks, the overall quality and minimal odor make them a fantastic option for your furry friend. The high standards of sourcing and preparation mean you can trust these bully sticks to be a beneficial addition to your dog's diet, offering both enjoyment and nutrition.

Mighty Paw Naturals Bully Sticks are a healthy, natural option for dogs of all sizes, made from a single ingredient that suits dogs with allergies to other proteins. However, many dog owners have reported a strong odor which can be off-putting, as well as inconsistent thickness. Despite these drawbacks, they remain a popular choice for some dog owners. It's important to weigh the pros and cons before deciding if these bully sticks are the right treat for your pet.

Pupford Thick Bully Sticks are marketed as a robust option for aggressive chewers, and their smoked flavor is intended to improve their smell, making them suitable for training purposes. However, numerous customers have reported significant issues with both the thickness and odor of these sticks.

Many users find the inconsistent thickness problematic, as it affects the durability and safety of the chew. Additionally, despite the smoking process, the odor remains a concern for some pet owners.

Downtown Pet Supply Bully Sticks are touted as a nutritious and healthy treat for dogs, promoting dental health and offering a natural chewing experience. However, many users have reported a strong odor and significant size inconsistencies, which can detract from their overall appeal. Their higher price point also contributes to making these bully sticks a less attractive option for many dog owners. The combination of odor issues, inconsistent sizing, and cost concerns suggests that there are better alternatives available on the market for those seeking a reliable and affordable chew for their pets.

Chew-e&Tasty Bully Sticks are marketed as a quality dog chew made from grass-fed, free-range beef, boasting high digestibility. However, many customers have reported inconsistencies in size, which can affect the chew's durability and safety.

Additionally, despite being advertised as odor-free, numerous users have complained about an unpleasant smell. These issues make Chew-e&Tasty Bully Sticks a less appealing choice for dog owners who prioritize consistent quality and a truly odor-free product.